23 / 02 / 2023

A Year of Collaborative Journalism to Face the War of Disinformation Since the Invasion of Ukraine

Since February 24, 2022, the best ally against disinformation has been collaboration among verification organizations and individuals skilled in open-source investigation. From ‘Maldita.es’, a journalistic approach from various angles has been taken: technology, community collaboration, with academic researchers and other organizations, education, social networks, and public policies.

Disinforming narratives that cross borders, decontextualized images, hoaxes that target the victims of the war. Facing the constant wave of disinformation that a war has unleashed, which has left thousands dead and injured, achieves greater reach if there is collaboration with the community and other organizations. This February 24 marks a year since the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and from Maldita.es we have verified and demonstrated that coordination and cooperation are the most effective approach to combat global disinformation.

An entire team dedicated to debunking more than 170 hoaxes about the war in Ukraine

Just a few minutes after the president of Russia, Vladimir Putin, officially announced the start of the attack on Ukraine, a flood of shocking images began to circulate on social networks, moving from one chat to another, even being broadcast on television.  Except some were real… and others were hoaxes .

In the early moments of the war, it was common to come across videos of conflicts that occurred in previous years, recorded in other countries, and even screenshots from video games. Therefore, the Maldita.es team set out to debunk hoaxes relentlessly, in a task especially intense in the first few weeks that evolved over time towards other types of more sophisticated disinformation, as we have described in this evolution of the hoaxes.

Among all the content you have consulted us on our WhatsApp chatbot (+34 644 22 93 19) and those we have been able to catch, in a year more than 170 hoaxes about the war in Ukraine have been dismantled, which we have compiled to understand their operation.

#UkraineFacts: a collaborative database among international fact-checkers to face a global disinformation campaign

All these lies, half-truths, and unproven disinformation have circulated around the world since February 24, 2022; and many of them were exactly the same but in different languages. The idea that this wave of disinformation would also be registering in other countries led Maldita.es to open a database and give access to more than 100 fact-checkers in 88 different countries to start collaborating, avoid duplicating efforts and analyze the phenomenon from a global approach.

Since then, #UkraineFacts has registered more than 2,800 debunkings and has obtained more than 150 national and international impacts as a source of information and mentions of its existence. This open tool attaches a map that allows access to debunking of the most viral hoaxes. In #UkraineFacts you can see in which countries each disinformation has been detected and access the debunking from different verification organizations that have investigated it.

Team O: the boost of open-source investigation and the OSINT community

In a war happening on our continent thousands of kilometers away and being told in real time on social networks, it was key to be able to geolocate, date or identify the ammunition used in attacks against civilians. For this reason, Maldita.es created ‘The O Team ‘. ‘O’ for OSINT, open-source investigation: a volunteer anti-hoax brigade to fight together against disinformation about the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Thanks to this team that has emerged in our community, joined by malditas and malditos who have lent us their superpowers related to OSINT and the Russian and Ukrainian languages, we have been able to conduct several investigations whose results and contributions to the accountability of the war have been recounted here. And the fruit of this collaboration in the daily work to address the authorship of the Bucha massacre, the explosion in the Mariupol theater or the missile that killed 60 Ukrainian civilians next to the Kramatorsk train station has led to subsequent collaborations.

Analysis of disinformation formats and study of the channels that share it

Identifying the formats of misinformation was one of the first tasks undertaken by Maldito Bulo and Maldita Educa teams. From subtitles that did not correspond to the audio to magazine covers that were never published, through false denials or false flag verifications or accusations against the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelensky, of being a Nazi or consuming cocaine. All these formats have been compiled to configure a catalog that would enable alerts to be raised when facing misinformation.

Furthermore, having identified the channels that tend to spread disinformation allowed us to conclude that those COVID-19 denier groups mutated into deniers of the Russian attacks with messages in favor of Putin. Telegram was one of the main scenarios in which these groups were identified, which gave rise to an investigation in which we analyzed the behavior of more than half a million messages from 39 channels that spread disinformation with more than 5,000 subscribers, which you can read here.

Precisely these groups were dedicated to viralizing hoaxes in Spanish that had been spread in other languages, the same phenomenon addressed by the global database of verifications of the Ukrainian war. Curious fact? The hoax that has been debunked the most times in the world, according to an analysis of the #UkraineFacts database, corresponds to images supposedly taken in Ukraine that supposedly showed fatal victims of Russian attacks moving in body bags but which was actually a climate protest in Austria. That same hoax reached 120,000 views on the channel of Rafapal, a well-known Spanish disinformer analyzed in the Maldita.es investigation ‘The Telegram Deniers’.

Sharing the acquired knowledge and circulating it

As we were learning and recording experiences, it was time to share the knowledge acquired. At Maldita.es we use a series of tools to fight disinformation and in the different talks, workshops and forums we usually explain how we use them so that you can also verify on your own. Some of them are tools such as InVid, Google Images reverse search or WayBack Machine, although we have also used geolocation maps such as Google Earth and even Wolfram Alpha Weather to determine the veracity of information. In addition to offering you our toolbox, Maldita Educa explains how to use each and every one of them with practical examples.

 

But not only there; If you are a regular at the daily twitcherias on our Twitch channel, you may remember a special resource to help you not get fooled by the hoaxes about the Russian invasion of Ukraine. And I’m sure you already know this, but we are very present on TikTok. So is the disinformation related to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, as this NewsGuard study warned about how this platform shows these contents to new users within minutes.  Therefore, in the midst of a wave of lies, half-truths, and decontextualized virals, the team got to work to spread the debunkings when we exceeded 100 hoaxes or in five compilations [which you can see here: 1 , 2 , 3, 4 and 5 ]. Remember! In crisis situations, do not share if you are not sure and send us everything that comes to you that makes you doubt at+34 644 229 319.

Collaboration network among organizations to study, understand, and fight disinformation

With all this background work, life continued at Maldita.es. The birth of the European Fact-Finding Standards Network (EFCSN) and its European Code of Professional Standards was formed precisely in the context of the war in Ukraine.  In this context, contacts with organizations based in Central and Eastern Europe, including Ukraine, have been strengthened, thus creating a dynamic of support for other verifiers, promoting the development of technical capabilities and training in skills (e.g. outreach) to strengthen the fight against disinformation in the region.

Maldita.es also participated in the working group of the European Union Disinformation Observatory, EDMO, on disinformation and the war in Ukraine. Here we have shared our daily observations, general trends and narratives, as well as recommendations to continue the fight against disinformation about the conflict. This exchange of views resulted in the final report published online.

During this crisis, platforms relied on content created by Maldita.es for dashboards or third-party checks (for example, Meta’s 3PFC). Better access to data for platforms that have signed the code is necessary to better understand the threat. We have contributed to the crisis response subgroup of the Code of Conduct on Disinformation by sharing information with the European Commission, ERGA, and other signatories, such as major online platforms, civil society organizations, and others.

Ralated news

29 / 07 / 2024

Maldita.es participates in the project QYourself to promote media literacy education in schools...

Maldita.es is participating in the project QYourself: Question what you get. Media education to combat disinformation led by the University of the...

24 / 07 / 2024

Maldita.es launches a service to report and prevent scams in its WhatsApp chatbot

At Maldita.es we are aware that we are all vulnerable to the scam attempts that cybercriminals try to sneak us in. For this reason...

22 / 07 / 2024

Platforms didn’t respond to half of the disinformation on EU elections 75% in the case of YouTube

Fundación Maldita has published a report assessing the response of Facebook Instagram TikTok X and YouTube to disinformation related to the European...